From the Feuilletons

Comments on the article: In Today's Feuilletons

11/05/2007

 
Noganote
(6 comments)
registered on 12/04/2007
Quote:
Amos Oz: "It is time to admit openly that we were responsible for the Palestinian refugee catastrophe. ... It is our duty to help work towards the resettlement of the refugees – in line with the peace agreement and beyond Israel's future peacetime borders."
Amos Oz should stick to writing fiction, and not try to fictionalize realities. Israel, by being created has brought upon it the wrath of the Arab world, the vanguard of which is the Palestinian people, as they attest in their own national charter (Articles 13, 14, 15 here: http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/Peace/PLO_Covenant.html).



There was a war, part of which was a civil war between Israelis and Arabs. The Arabs lost the war that they had started, and as in every war, there were refugees, who either fled, encouraged to flee or forced to flee. The Palestinian refugees were no different. The only distinction is that while war refugees are integrated within a few years in new homelands of similar ethnicity and language, Palestinian refugees were made to keep their unique status of eternal refugee. So now we have the fourth-generation refugees demanding Israel accept responsibility for them.



By the same token, the grandchildren and great-grandchildren of Jewish refugees from Arab lands who either fled, encouraged to flee or forced to flee with the creation of Israel should demand from Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, Morrocco, Tunisia, Egypt, etc., accountabilty and financial compensation for their lost assets. Unfortunately for them, their claims have long been forgotten and there are no special UN institutions to look after them, the way there are for Palestinians.



As long as Arabs and Palestinian-Arabs cling to the myth of Israel’s blanket criminality, eschew all responsibility for creating, or at least contributing heavily, to their own malaise, there will be no progress towards compromise. Oz is hoping for Arab generosity. If Israel were but to acknowledge that it was responsible for the creation of the Palestinian problem, then the Arabs would reciprocate in kind and we can all sing kumbaya.



As if anything Israel does or says can sway the frozen-solid hatred of something like this: http://www.solomonia.com/blog/archives/010465.shtml. Let’s not forget that Hamas was elected fair and square, in a democratic process, by the majority of Palestinians. It seems reasonable to assume that such ideology and sentiments are therefore supported by the majority of Palestinians.



Amos Oz’s well-intentioned thinking is like trying to empty the ocean one teaspoon at a time. Israelis are willing to cut deeply into their own flesh if it makes a difference in Arab rejectionism. But they won’t commit national suicide.
Created on 11/05/2007 | Reviewed on 14/05/2007
› Report this comment to editors
to rate a comment › login
Rating: (0 users rated)

Write a comment

You have to › login to write a comment.